| PAST PSAA CHAMPIONS | |||||
| 2024-24 | LWA | ||||
| 2022-23 | Portledge | ||||
| 2021-22 | Portledge | ||||
| 2020-21 | Portledge | ||||
| 2019-20 | Evangel Christian | ||||
| 2018-19 | Knox | ||||
| 2017-18 | Knox | ||||
| 2016-17 | LWA | ||||
| 2015-16 | LWA | ||||
| 2014-15 | UNIS | ||||
| 2013-14 | Our Savior Lutheran | ||||
| 2012-13 | LWA | ||||
| 2011-12 | LWA | ||||
| 2010-11 | LWA | ||||
| 2009-10 | LWA | ||||
| 2008-09 | LWA | ||||
| 2007-08 | LWA | ||||
| 2006-07 | Adelphi Prep | ||||
| 2005-06 | Kew Forest | ||||
| 2004-05 | Our Savior Lutheran | ||||
| 2003-04 | Adelphi Prep | ||||
| 2002-03 | Martin Luther | ||||
| 2001-02 | Staten Island Academy | ||||
| 2000-01 | Our Savior Lutheran | ||||
| 1999-00 | Our Savior Lutheran | ||||
| 1998-99 | UNIS | ||||
| 1997-98 | Our Savior Lutheran | ||||
| 1996-97 | Cathedral Prep | ||||
| 1995-96 | Cathedral Prep | ||||
| 1994-95 | Cathedral Prep | ||||
| 1993-94 | Smithtown Christian | ||||
| 1992-93 | Our Savior Lutheran | ||||
| 1991-92 | Martin Luther | ||||
| 1990-91 | Friends Academy | ||||
| 1989-90 | Friends Academy | ||||
| 1988-89 | Our Savior Lutheran | ||||
| 1987-88 | Our Savior Lutheran | ||||
| 1986-87 | Our Savior Lutheran | ||||